Friday, October 20, 2006

Curing Poverty Part 1 of ?

How do you stop poverty? Do you take it head on from the top down or bottom up? When we donate millions upon millions to help impoverished individuals and families in third world countries is that helping at all? The factors are obvious at first, then you start to look deeper. There is a saying, dont give them fish teach them to fish. Assume you accomplish teaching someone how to fish and they create a living for themselves by doing so. Everything is fine until they see another fisherman in a boat haul up 200x more fish than he is, making that much more and works less hours. On top of which that guy in the boat is going to put your fisherman out of business because he can sell the fish for much cheaper! This in turn threatens his families very livelihood. Your student wants to do the same thing so what does he do? He tries to buy a boat. Can he afford to? Most probably not since he does not make enough money to buy a boat. So is there a way around this dilemma? Always. An example might be that he knows who gives out fishing licenses and asks him for a favor. Something to the tune of dont renew his fishing license that way you can fine him and keep the money yourself. In return Ill give you 5% of my catch These small interactions change the way the system works.

We in the western world assume that we can just teach people how to get to a certain level of lifestyle. What we do not understand is the fact that while we are showing people how to fish at the same time we are marketing the luxuries of life. They see what we consume and naturally they want what they see. It is only human. So what happens on a large scale? Those who have money will go out and buy as much luxury goods as they can while the others watch and want. This breeds the wrong type of materialism. Its the cycle of poverty common in Southeast Asian countries and other third world countries. They see these material things and those who arent smart enough or patient enough to get into a good paying job, steal. Not only do they steal from the haves but they also steal from the have nots. And those who get a job? Well, once you achieve something you have always wanted you defend it. Not only that but eventually you want more and more at any cost.

I want to bring up the case of Haile Selassie in Ethiopia and the famine he caused. There were various factors to the whole situation but essentially what it came down to was money. Selassie was the Emperor of Ethiopia and as so would dictate matters from trade and commerce to your everyday laws and whatever so pleased him, essentially. Another note to keep in mind is farming. There are essentially two types of crops, subsistence crops which keep you alive and there are luxuries such as grapes, strawberries and cotton which no one can really live off of. Despite that fact they fetch a significant amount more in the market place.

Also keep in mind that virtually everyone in Selassies empire was poor unless you were one of his cronies (especially since he would tax the hell out of his people). Therefore the argument that the people cold sell their crops amongst themselves to make money and buy food falls apart.

In order to increase the trade profits Selassie increased the production of luxury crops and decreased the production of subsistence crops. This greatly increased his profits and greatly decreased the amount of food available to the masses. Take a look at the price effects this would have locally. Since you are producing less subsistence crops and the demand is so high the prices would be extraordinarily high for food locally. Luxury goods would be cheaper to eat but people cannot survive on strawberries and cotton. In the Imports market those luxury goods would fetch a significant amount and the sale of which went straight to Selassies coffers. Essentially he screwed his own people and kept the money.

Our natural response to a situation such as this is to send money and food and anything else to help for that matter. What message does this response send to those in power and are corrupt? It says Go ahead, steal the money which should be going to your people because we are going to take care of them while you do that. This is assuming that the corrupt arent taking all that aid in the first place. The significance of it is the fact that responsibility has totally been shifted. Their response to it; Go ahead, less of a headache for me!

So on one side we promote consumption. We promote the better life. Impoverished people see this and say, I want that too. How do I get that? Then the fight to the top begins. The masses of the industrial world see this and step up to give aid only to continuously fan the flames. Here is the real kick in the nuts though are you ready?

Economies transition from commodities (goods) based economies to knowledge-based economies. Commodities based economies run on the raw materials that they sell and knowledge-based economies run on intellectual property, intangibles such as services (consulting, internet etc.). The more prosperous the country the more knowledge-based their economy is. Lets take a look at this on a goods traded level. When you transition from commodities based to a knowledge-based economy you export less raw materials and more intellectual property. This is because a knowledge-based economy needs those raw materials for itself in order to function. The local price of those raw materials increase as costs increase due to demand, land value and say cost of labor increasing with cost of living because the economy is doing so well (gotta pay more!!). So if your local price is so expensive where do you go? To somewhere they are cheaper, a third world country for example! COOL! Ok. So what happens when the countries you get your raw materials from progress from a commodities based economy to a knowledge-based economy? The price of raw materials in that country increases.

Why is this the real kick in the nuts? Well, if your country needs those raw materials and the price of those raw materials increase what happens at home? Everything gets expensive. Im sure you all know what Im talking about. No? Well, lets put it this way, it is almost cheaper to fly to Boston from DC than it is to drive it. Thats another story though. Essentially what Im saying is that it is in the best interests of ANY industrialized nation to keep a non-industrialized nation from industrializing. Imagine if the US had the same amount of resources (adjusted per square mile) as Indonesia. It would have the potential to not only be the last standing superpower but to also be able to be self-sufficient.

It is that one last factor which makes all the difference. We all bitch and moan about how people are suffering around the world but are we ready for the consequences of fully devoting ourselves to a cause which would change our everyday lives? I think it is possible. I believe that the solution lies within the private sector. So, how do you stop poverty?

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home