Friday, October 20, 2006

Curing Poverty Part 2 of ?

What would I do? There is not a single position or approach to take. I believe that you would have to take and eclectic stand. All angles have to be covered. Naturally it is pretty much impossible to see the absolute annihilation of poverty, although there are significant steps that could close the gap between the degrees of poverty. I guess I should have defined my perspective of poverty in the first posting, my apologies. Poverty to me covers a range of people who are unable to care for themselves or families sufficiently in the following categories: financially, healthcare, and basic survival needs. More specifically, (to me) poverty is, to a great degree in Southeast Asia, a side effect of corruption, economic instability and circumstance.

Having lived in Asia most my life, seeing a lot of healthy (and by healthy I mean they, for the most part, have all their extremities, digits and are not emaciated) homeless people and beggars on the streets here in the US completely threw me off. Especially obese beggars, that really threw me off because how do the two correlate? Anyone who has lived in Southeast Asia knows (probably with the exception of Singapore) that if you are impoverished in Asia, you are REALLY not doing well. Walking down the street in Manila, Bangkok, Jakarta, or Kuala Lumpur, you would be hard pressed to avoid seeing the surreal conditions in which people have to live in.

In SE Asia, there are a lot of poor people who work their asses off and get nowhere. Generally they are vendors of various things or perhaps they are in the service industry. Service industry ranges from domestic help to sexual favors. You have poor people who come from rural areas where their family probably has a lot of land and is set in a beautiful location. These people come to the big city in hopes of making more money and soon realize that A: they do not realize how or where to get a job and B: there is no way home because they go broke really quickly in the big city. The common story is that of the rural girl coming to the big city, getting used and being left. They turn or are forced into prostitution or they meet someone they thought would take care of them, get knocked up, and then left on the street with a bun in the oven. This happens to prostitutes as well. If they contract a disease they are thrown out like a rag. If they have a child they give the child to an orphanage. Those children in turn are thrown into a life of poverty. And so the cycle continues.

Then you have the beggars and homeless people. In SE Asia there two subcategories within this tier; those who are homeless/beg due to circumstance and those who were forced into begging. Apparently getting people on the streets to beg for you is pretty lucrative. So, the local crime organizations got in on the game. Traitors, drug addicts who couldnt pay, drug dealers who stole, anyone who owed them something or crossed their path was fair game for employment in the canvassing of entire cities in order to pick up as much cash as possible. Tourists are always suckers, and Ill say this (again) to anyone visiting a SE Asian country; DO NOT GIVE MONEY TO THE PEOPLE BEGGING, ESPECIALLY IF THEY ARE MAIMED. It does not benefit them, in fact it keeps them on the street. They are maimed not because of circumstance or actual health related issues. They are maimed because they screwed up and messed with someone they should not have had any involvement with. That person was maimed for two reasons; primarily so that they wont forget their mistake and second, people are more apt to give money to a disabled person begging for money than just any another person begging for money. The fact that they are disabled triggers a justification (in our minds) as to why he is begging. It is just a ploy. Dont believe me? Ok, try giving him something he could really use, then take a look at the response you get and you be the judge of things.

Let me give you a personal experience. When I was in the fifth grade in Jakarta, Indonesia, my mother and I decided to gather all of my old clothes and personally go under a highway overpass and give away all of our old clothes, some toys and a lot of food (Indonesian brands of food BTW) to a homeless family we had seen before. Under this overpass lived seven to eight children with their mom in a makeshift cardboard house. We pull up and they immediately run to us from off the streets (where they were begging) and start asking us for money. Instead we brought out the boxes and started giving it to the kids, explaining that it was meant for them. One of the children was called over by their mother (who never approached us) she had a brief look at the merchandise and promptly sent the child back. When the little boy came back he said something in Indonesian (in a dialect I did not understand) and all of them dropped everything they were picking up back into the boxes and ran back to the street. All with the exception of the one child who had a word with the mother. He offered to throw away our trash for a nominal fee. He was indeed a liaison. We declined and took the items to an orphanage where they gladly accepted our donation.

In the last posting I gave a general outline into one of the many machinations of poverty in the third world. Corruption is undoubtedly the keystone. Focusing efforts on corruption does not change the lives of the many impoverished people in TWCs on its own. Dont get me wrong, by significantly reducing corruption the cycle would be completely thrown off and it is definitely the first fight I would keep my eye on. The very idea would imply a great deal of things but primarily it lead to a freeing up of capital and a reduction of power held by these organized groups. As I stated earlier taking on one function of such a complex machine is not enough. It has to be a huge and well orchestrated effort. You need to have the funds, the political clout, mass marketing efforts, a lot of educators and social workers and private organizations willing to go an extra step. That is the first tough part. The second hard part is getting people to be willing to accept the changes and implications of significantly reducing poverty. More on that on the next posting.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home