Friday, October 20, 2006

Curing Poverty Part 4 of ?

In my previous postings I focused on the external economic approach to providing a solution for poverty. I feel that I need to emphasize on the socio-political approaches that are important as well because as I said there is not one solution there are many. These many solution also have to work together in unison. These are the three subtopics I want to cover:

I. Revolution, People Power and Martial Law

II. Policies

III. The Ideal Leader

I. Revolution, People Power and Martial Law

There has to be a great movement, a push against corruption by individuals as a whole. My idea of the private sector taking a major role is only a salve to cure the legions. What we essentially need is chemotherapy. What I mean by this is that in countries like the Philippines, there is no easy approach to dismantling the mechanism of corruption. This is where I will dare to make a very contentious stance. In order to break something efficiently you need to know how it works and not only that but you need to know where to break it to maximize the effect. You have to go commercial I you are independent and radical. Take Rage Against the Machine for example. In order to get their radical message across you need a very large audience. So why would you go through the pain of going with a small record label? It is not worth ones time. You go big and you go corporate: SONY.

I believe that it is the same in a corrupt system. If you attempt to break a corrupt mechanism from the outside you are bound to be assassinated, take the late opposition senator Benigno Aquino who fought the Marcos regime and was assassinated. His wife later became president but still was unable to break the corrupt mechanisms. The approach to be taken is a hard, bloody and just as deadly to oneself. If you are a genuine leader of the people (using the Philippines as an example) and you want to break the system this is my outline:

1. Assimilate into the corrupt system and know it very well. Amass a significant amount of money and rise up very high into the ranks, as close to the presidency as possible.

2. With the money and power assimilated buy out the masses and make sure the Catholic church is on your side. This will be your support platform. Keep in mind the military and know what loyalties the generals have. Militaries love to know that the best thing is for them to run the country. Hint that you believe martial law is the way to go, get them on your side.

3. Know who all the key players are, what they do and who they are connected to.

4. Help create a situation that creates significant animosity amongst the populace towards the government. It is at this point that key players in the corrupt system need to be eliminated. This will create chaos and a platform from which you can launch your revolution.

5. Let your people rise together and begin to look at who stands with you. Hold them close because they will inherit your government. Make sure there is a good fusion between the military and the people.

6. When the dust settles and the revolution is over immediately impose martial law and continue the elimination and/or exiling of the corrupt.

II. Policies

Once gain, when I am thinking of these policies I have my home country of the Philippines in mind.

Economically, the new government must focus on stabilization and internal growth. It must also pull off what I call a Singapore Maneuver and what I mean by this is during the period of martial law you have to initiate strict laws which involves a lot of fines. For example in the case of littering, if a person is caught littering they should be given three choices; 1. Pay a ridiculous fine that they cannot afford to pay 2. Do community service hours equaling the amount of the fine or 3. Go to jail where you will have to do community service and be imprisoned. These laws will help solve budget issues and will help to rebuild the infrastructure of the country. On top of which it will help to instill a feeling of responsibility to the country which has been lacking in the Philippines for quite a while.

During this time it would also be wise to do your best to keep any of the influences of corruption at a minimal. One way of doing so is to make it a crime against the state, seen as a terrorist act and use the military to deal with such incidents.

Marketing efforts at this time would have to be in full swing. A sense of nationalism needs to me re-instilled.

III. The Ideal Leader

The ideal leader is one that does not care for the benefits of power but the benefits of the country. Yes, almost impossible. A true humanitarian who is not scared to make unpopular decisions and someone who is willing to relinquish his position once the era of marital law is over. This person has to be strong and understand that there is a good chance that you may die at the hands of those who were once corrupt and are trying to get back in. Most importantly, it must be someone who has seen the horrors which plague the country. Such people do exist, they just die before they are able to do anything.

Poverty is just a symptom of an entirely corrupt system. If you want to cure poverty remember that there are other battles that need to be taken up first. My ideas are just that, my ideas. Therein lies the inherent problem of life. In order to do something about something you must impose your ideas. You have to have enough balls to say that your way is right and assume that people will agree with you. Most of the time people do not want to deal with what is involved. I leave you with words from Einstein.

Great spirits have often encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds.

Curing Poverty Part 3 of ?

I'm sure that my solution to poverty may come off as naïve to some of my audience, but what the heck. Its my first blog Ill just say what I have to say.

I dont believe that the solution lies solely on the public sector. I do not think that they have the necessary resources (including money) to carry out such a task. In fact looking at things from a macro perspective, I wouldnt think that they would want to help out anyway. In fact I would go so far as to say that any government would be happy to not worry about poverty in their nation so long as crime rates, drug trafficking and unemployment rates are under control.

I believe that the solution lies within the private sector and individuals as a whole. In a world of ever rising costs the private sector should consider viewing those that are impoverished as potential employees and potential markets. I say this because I refuse to believe that a human being cannot be trained to do anything. So how do you get these people to be up to any standard? Thats where the funding, education and marketing comes in. When I am thinking of this solution I generally am thinking of Southeast Asia. Imagine a charitable organization that does more than just give out cash and medical supplies. What if you could gather a significant workforce and create government and private sector (with tax incentives) contracts to clean the city streets or company facilities at competitive (profitable but not extremely so) prices. Understandably there may not be a lot of money to be made but since you are a charitable organization the objective would be to keep your overhead as low as possible by receiving funds and donations (a large annual donation for supplies from different companies for example). All the profits would go to educational programs, but more importantly to pay your workforce. I believe that establishing a sense of accomplishment in persons, who have been knocked down all their lives, is extremely important. Childcare services and education can be provided while parents are working. I believe that this approach is one of many that can be taken but what differentiates this approach is the fact that you minimize state involvement so that it is easier to maneuver, you take into account accountability (you dont just give fish) and you can create structure in peoples lives where previously you would only find despair and uncertainty. The overall objective of this organization would be to get people into a position where they could be hired and maybe find their own sea legs (so to speak). Instead of directly competing why not provide a hiring service to service firms?

Just as a side note. I would love to get into more detail about this entire issue. I feel like I am giving you only the cliffs notes version of things. I apologize and I do realize this. At the same time Im sure that you could do without all the mundane details.

I ask if people are really ready to take on the poverty issue because to me, as a business minded person, the implications and the potential effects in the long run will create great changes in the daily lives of many people. Consider the best possible outcome; say reducing poverty by 90% in the pacific rim. 90% is a lot of people for governments to take care of and economies to allow into the workforce. Consider unemployment rates. Everyone thinks that the best unemployment rate is 0%. Unfortunately it is not. 3.5% is the lowest it should go, any lower would suggest that the economy is overheating. At the same time unemployment rates cannot exceed 5.5% or else it could be considered that the economy is recessing. So what happens if you are able to reduce poverty by 90% in the Pacific Rim? Does that mean we are better off or not? Why is the unemployment rate going to affect daily lives? Well, it is an economic indicator. People may lose a lot of jobs and businesses could stand to create significant profits. It all cycles back.

If we are better off that would suggest a better world right? Less poverty? O.k. but what if that leads to a significant amount of people in the workforce? Granted it may not be people who grow up to become executives and CEOs but those arent the people that run the world. They just try to point the direction in which things flow. The people that run the world are operational. So given the fact that there are certain limits to the unemployment rate the suggestion would be that in order to accommodate the increase in the potential workforce, the economy would have to grow significantly. This is why my focus is on S.E.A. because they have the potential for that growth, a significant amount of workforce and potential workforce.

If the economy doesnt grow fast enough though, like in the western world, then you would have an excessive workforce but not only that, in terms of competition you would be selling for cheaper and thus undercutting. This may lead to further unemployment because other firms may have to restructure (laying off people) in order to stay competitive with you.

Perhaps once the changes start to materialize people would regret it?

The positive thing about caring for these issues now lies not only in the effects it has but the fact that people are becoming more selfless. In essence that is what it will take, selflessness; the ability to say o.k. Ill take the personal financial losses in order for the world to be a better, fairer place. Like everything there are pros and cons. Unfortunately the way our societies are set up; just remember that someone has to be a have not if you are to be a have

Curing Poverty Part 2 of ?

What would I do? There is not a single position or approach to take. I believe that you would have to take and eclectic stand. All angles have to be covered. Naturally it is pretty much impossible to see the absolute annihilation of poverty, although there are significant steps that could close the gap between the degrees of poverty. I guess I should have defined my perspective of poverty in the first posting, my apologies. Poverty to me covers a range of people who are unable to care for themselves or families sufficiently in the following categories: financially, healthcare, and basic survival needs. More specifically, (to me) poverty is, to a great degree in Southeast Asia, a side effect of corruption, economic instability and circumstance.

Having lived in Asia most my life, seeing a lot of healthy (and by healthy I mean they, for the most part, have all their extremities, digits and are not emaciated) homeless people and beggars on the streets here in the US completely threw me off. Especially obese beggars, that really threw me off because how do the two correlate? Anyone who has lived in Southeast Asia knows (probably with the exception of Singapore) that if you are impoverished in Asia, you are REALLY not doing well. Walking down the street in Manila, Bangkok, Jakarta, or Kuala Lumpur, you would be hard pressed to avoid seeing the surreal conditions in which people have to live in.

In SE Asia, there are a lot of poor people who work their asses off and get nowhere. Generally they are vendors of various things or perhaps they are in the service industry. Service industry ranges from domestic help to sexual favors. You have poor people who come from rural areas where their family probably has a lot of land and is set in a beautiful location. These people come to the big city in hopes of making more money and soon realize that A: they do not realize how or where to get a job and B: there is no way home because they go broke really quickly in the big city. The common story is that of the rural girl coming to the big city, getting used and being left. They turn or are forced into prostitution or they meet someone they thought would take care of them, get knocked up, and then left on the street with a bun in the oven. This happens to prostitutes as well. If they contract a disease they are thrown out like a rag. If they have a child they give the child to an orphanage. Those children in turn are thrown into a life of poverty. And so the cycle continues.

Then you have the beggars and homeless people. In SE Asia there two subcategories within this tier; those who are homeless/beg due to circumstance and those who were forced into begging. Apparently getting people on the streets to beg for you is pretty lucrative. So, the local crime organizations got in on the game. Traitors, drug addicts who couldnt pay, drug dealers who stole, anyone who owed them something or crossed their path was fair game for employment in the canvassing of entire cities in order to pick up as much cash as possible. Tourists are always suckers, and Ill say this (again) to anyone visiting a SE Asian country; DO NOT GIVE MONEY TO THE PEOPLE BEGGING, ESPECIALLY IF THEY ARE MAIMED. It does not benefit them, in fact it keeps them on the street. They are maimed not because of circumstance or actual health related issues. They are maimed because they screwed up and messed with someone they should not have had any involvement with. That person was maimed for two reasons; primarily so that they wont forget their mistake and second, people are more apt to give money to a disabled person begging for money than just any another person begging for money. The fact that they are disabled triggers a justification (in our minds) as to why he is begging. It is just a ploy. Dont believe me? Ok, try giving him something he could really use, then take a look at the response you get and you be the judge of things.

Let me give you a personal experience. When I was in the fifth grade in Jakarta, Indonesia, my mother and I decided to gather all of my old clothes and personally go under a highway overpass and give away all of our old clothes, some toys and a lot of food (Indonesian brands of food BTW) to a homeless family we had seen before. Under this overpass lived seven to eight children with their mom in a makeshift cardboard house. We pull up and they immediately run to us from off the streets (where they were begging) and start asking us for money. Instead we brought out the boxes and started giving it to the kids, explaining that it was meant for them. One of the children was called over by their mother (who never approached us) she had a brief look at the merchandise and promptly sent the child back. When the little boy came back he said something in Indonesian (in a dialect I did not understand) and all of them dropped everything they were picking up back into the boxes and ran back to the street. All with the exception of the one child who had a word with the mother. He offered to throw away our trash for a nominal fee. He was indeed a liaison. We declined and took the items to an orphanage where they gladly accepted our donation.

In the last posting I gave a general outline into one of the many machinations of poverty in the third world. Corruption is undoubtedly the keystone. Focusing efforts on corruption does not change the lives of the many impoverished people in TWCs on its own. Dont get me wrong, by significantly reducing corruption the cycle would be completely thrown off and it is definitely the first fight I would keep my eye on. The very idea would imply a great deal of things but primarily it lead to a freeing up of capital and a reduction of power held by these organized groups. As I stated earlier taking on one function of such a complex machine is not enough. It has to be a huge and well orchestrated effort. You need to have the funds, the political clout, mass marketing efforts, a lot of educators and social workers and private organizations willing to go an extra step. That is the first tough part. The second hard part is getting people to be willing to accept the changes and implications of significantly reducing poverty. More on that on the next posting.

Curing Poverty Part 1 of ?

How do you stop poverty? Do you take it head on from the top down or bottom up? When we donate millions upon millions to help impoverished individuals and families in third world countries is that helping at all? The factors are obvious at first, then you start to look deeper. There is a saying, dont give them fish teach them to fish. Assume you accomplish teaching someone how to fish and they create a living for themselves by doing so. Everything is fine until they see another fisherman in a boat haul up 200x more fish than he is, making that much more and works less hours. On top of which that guy in the boat is going to put your fisherman out of business because he can sell the fish for much cheaper! This in turn threatens his families very livelihood. Your student wants to do the same thing so what does he do? He tries to buy a boat. Can he afford to? Most probably not since he does not make enough money to buy a boat. So is there a way around this dilemma? Always. An example might be that he knows who gives out fishing licenses and asks him for a favor. Something to the tune of dont renew his fishing license that way you can fine him and keep the money yourself. In return Ill give you 5% of my catch These small interactions change the way the system works.

We in the western world assume that we can just teach people how to get to a certain level of lifestyle. What we do not understand is the fact that while we are showing people how to fish at the same time we are marketing the luxuries of life. They see what we consume and naturally they want what they see. It is only human. So what happens on a large scale? Those who have money will go out and buy as much luxury goods as they can while the others watch and want. This breeds the wrong type of materialism. Its the cycle of poverty common in Southeast Asian countries and other third world countries. They see these material things and those who arent smart enough or patient enough to get into a good paying job, steal. Not only do they steal from the haves but they also steal from the have nots. And those who get a job? Well, once you achieve something you have always wanted you defend it. Not only that but eventually you want more and more at any cost.

I want to bring up the case of Haile Selassie in Ethiopia and the famine he caused. There were various factors to the whole situation but essentially what it came down to was money. Selassie was the Emperor of Ethiopia and as so would dictate matters from trade and commerce to your everyday laws and whatever so pleased him, essentially. Another note to keep in mind is farming. There are essentially two types of crops, subsistence crops which keep you alive and there are luxuries such as grapes, strawberries and cotton which no one can really live off of. Despite that fact they fetch a significant amount more in the market place.

Also keep in mind that virtually everyone in Selassies empire was poor unless you were one of his cronies (especially since he would tax the hell out of his people). Therefore the argument that the people cold sell their crops amongst themselves to make money and buy food falls apart.

In order to increase the trade profits Selassie increased the production of luxury crops and decreased the production of subsistence crops. This greatly increased his profits and greatly decreased the amount of food available to the masses. Take a look at the price effects this would have locally. Since you are producing less subsistence crops and the demand is so high the prices would be extraordinarily high for food locally. Luxury goods would be cheaper to eat but people cannot survive on strawberries and cotton. In the Imports market those luxury goods would fetch a significant amount and the sale of which went straight to Selassies coffers. Essentially he screwed his own people and kept the money.

Our natural response to a situation such as this is to send money and food and anything else to help for that matter. What message does this response send to those in power and are corrupt? It says Go ahead, steal the money which should be going to your people because we are going to take care of them while you do that. This is assuming that the corrupt arent taking all that aid in the first place. The significance of it is the fact that responsibility has totally been shifted. Their response to it; Go ahead, less of a headache for me!

So on one side we promote consumption. We promote the better life. Impoverished people see this and say, I want that too. How do I get that? Then the fight to the top begins. The masses of the industrial world see this and step up to give aid only to continuously fan the flames. Here is the real kick in the nuts though are you ready?

Economies transition from commodities (goods) based economies to knowledge-based economies. Commodities based economies run on the raw materials that they sell and knowledge-based economies run on intellectual property, intangibles such as services (consulting, internet etc.). The more prosperous the country the more knowledge-based their economy is. Lets take a look at this on a goods traded level. When you transition from commodities based to a knowledge-based economy you export less raw materials and more intellectual property. This is because a knowledge-based economy needs those raw materials for itself in order to function. The local price of those raw materials increase as costs increase due to demand, land value and say cost of labor increasing with cost of living because the economy is doing so well (gotta pay more!!). So if your local price is so expensive where do you go? To somewhere they are cheaper, a third world country for example! COOL! Ok. So what happens when the countries you get your raw materials from progress from a commodities based economy to a knowledge-based economy? The price of raw materials in that country increases.

Why is this the real kick in the nuts? Well, if your country needs those raw materials and the price of those raw materials increase what happens at home? Everything gets expensive. Im sure you all know what Im talking about. No? Well, lets put it this way, it is almost cheaper to fly to Boston from DC than it is to drive it. Thats another story though. Essentially what Im saying is that it is in the best interests of ANY industrialized nation to keep a non-industrialized nation from industrializing. Imagine if the US had the same amount of resources (adjusted per square mile) as Indonesia. It would have the potential to not only be the last standing superpower but to also be able to be self-sufficient.

It is that one last factor which makes all the difference. We all bitch and moan about how people are suffering around the world but are we ready for the consequences of fully devoting ourselves to a cause which would change our everyday lives? I think it is possible. I believe that the solution lies within the private sector. So, how do you stop poverty?